Yesterday, you read about the 7,000 people who trekked to Susan B. Anthony’s gravesite to pay an Election Day tribute. In one of many examples, preservationist James Caffrey taught us about Rochester’s famed poet Adelaide Crapsey and the unrequited love of famed architect Claude Bragdon.
Today, George Payne enriches our aesthetic, intellectual, religious and mystical understanding of America’s oldest Victorian cemetery.
Photos by George with links to Mt. Hope articles by George and others.
Mt. Hope’s Subconscious Side: Symbolizing Life and Death in America’s Oldest Victorian Cemetery by George Payne
Mount Hope Cemetery, one of the most remarkable Victorian cemeteries in America, is a magnificent 196 acres of lofty hills and picturesque valleys created by glaciers and transformed into a beautiful historic cemetery. A diversified forest of trees forms an arboretum shading thousands of marble, bronze, and granite monuments. The cemetery is a veritable museum of funerary sculpture and mausoleums spanning more than a century and a half.
No one can confidently say that he will still be living tomorrow.
ABOUT THE FRIENDS OF MOUNT HOPE CEMETERY
The Friends of Mount Hope Cemetery is a non-profit organization of volunteers founded in 1980 to restore, preserve, and encourage public use and enjoyment of this unique historical treasure. We have a wealth of resources available to help you learn about our community as reflected in the lives of those who chose Mount Hope Cemetery as their final resting place. Susan B. Anthony and her family, Frederick Douglass and family, Isaac and Amy Post, John Jacob Bausch and Henry Lomb (of Bausch and Lomb eyewear fame), Emily Sibley Watson, Margaret Woodbury Strong, and Reverend Thomas James are all here (to name a few), and they have much to tell us about the growing pains our nation continues to experience: issues of human rights, commerce, the power of government and the responsibility of the governed.
The Friends have been instrumental in completing a number of improvements throughout the cemetery. Projects such as the restoration of the 1872 Moorish gazebo, upgrades to the 1874 High Victorian Gothic gatehouse, repair of the Florentine fountain, and the restoration of the Charles Rau mausoleum have been completed. Each year new historically important projects are organized.
Cynthia Howk, architectural research coordinator at the Landmark Society of Western New York, thinks that Mt. Hope has more than a good shot at earning a place on the national register, which is an official list of places deemed worthy of preservation.
“It has enormous cultural, social, architectural, artistic significance in all those categories,” Howk said. “Even if you’re not from Rochester and don’t necessarily have any family members there, it’s a place that really should be visited. It’s really quite beautiful and dramatic.”
It’s not that Mt. Hope has gone unacknowledged all these years.
The northern portion of the city-owned cemetery already is listed in the national register as part of the Mt. Hope/Highland Historic District. Established in 1974, the district also includes all of Highland Park, as well as the Ellwanger Estate and other historic homes along Mt. Hope Avenue.
But historians today might scratch their heads why the boundary lines were drawn as they were, Howk said, excluding roughly half the cemetery while looping in adjacent areas. Howk said she thinks it makes sense to now seek recognition for the entire cemetery as its own distinct site.
The Mt. Hope site was formed by glaciers that left behind rolling hills and gullies. Departing from tradition, its designers chose to leave the landscape as it was instead of trying to level it. At the time, it was the closest that the city had to a public park, and many residents picnicked there, Howk said.
“The city of Rochester was very much on the cutting edge,” she said.