Baseball was better 45 years ago

Baseball was better 45 years ago

see Make Predictions. Win cash.

In Make Predictions. Win cash. , we enticed people to make their 2017 baseball predictions with the succulent reward of a sweet Benny F $100 bill. In addition, to get your hardball Nostradamus juices flowing, we purchased the 1972 Street and Smith’s from Yankee Peddler in the Village Gate for $18.

We chose the 1972 edition for several reasons. Tragically, Roberto Clemente died helping Nicaraguan earthquake victims after the 1972 season.  I never had the chance to actually watch Clemente play, although his 1973 Topps card is among the treasured in my collection.


1972 Street & Smith’s. Unbeknownst to S & S, May would be traded to the Met before the 1972 season. He became the spiritual leader of the Mets when they fell short in the 7th game of the 1973 World Series. see On Yogi Berra and Dale Berra and the 1973 World Series and Willie Mays and my father

As seen in On Yogi Berra and Dale Berra and the 1973 World Series and Willie Mays and my father , I did not watch my first baseball games until 1973 when we followed Willie Mays all the way to the on deck circle in the 7th game.

Reading about 1972 — the year before my baseball birth — is a little like reflecting upon events before you were conceived: only existing in the mythical imagination of cards and magazine covers or 45 years later on old tv clips from the A’s-Reds World Series.

And, as we wrote about in 45 years ago when the Pittsburgh Pirates fielded a team of “All brothers out there” , there was Roberto on the field with his eight brothers en route to the 1971 championship.

1971 world series

1972 S & S

A baseball fan — purist or contemp — walks into different diamond when reopening the crinkling pages of the 1972 S & S.

Times of Game

For several years now, MLB has tried to shorten the length of games to little avail.  Today, baseball games are too long. People think baseball is slow and slow paced. But remember, games used to be played often in less than two hours — even in the World Series.

S & S always had a feature on the previous years World Series.  And the times of the games was stunning: G1-2:06; G2-2:55;  G3-2:20; G4-2:48 (this, the first night game in baseball history, was viewed by 61 million); G5-2:16; G6-2:59; G7-2:10

Now compare that with the 7 games of the 2016 World Series: 3:37, 4:04, 3:33, 3:16, 3: 27, 3:29, 4:28.

That’s about 17.5 hours for seven games in 1971 and 26 for hours for seven games in 2016.  Whether greedy tv executives or the glacial pace of play today are to blame, baseball was better in 1972.

The Reserve Clause-Player Movement-Player Salaries

In 1972, baseball still had the reserve clause that prevented players from freely negotiating with any team other than the one that originally signed them.

The reserve clause kept ballplayers’ salaries almost unfathomably low compared with today.

In 1972, the S & S reported that a dozen players had broken the $100,000 mark (about 600,000 in today’s dollars).  Keep in mind that today the minimum salary is 440,000; while the top superstars command 20 million a year.

In 1972, the entire payroll of the Texas Rangers was 194,000!

see 1972 Attendance-payroll-game times

Al kaline

1972 S & S

The conservative, pro-establishment Street & Smith’s took a dim view player resistance to the reserve clause.  After Curt Flood tried to have the Supreme Court overturn the clause, the editors disputed Curt Flood’s claim that the clause was “a form of serfdom” — especially since Flood was making 90,000 a year. (Today a player of his caliber would be about 100 times that amount.)

The reserve clause was unfair; it was fiefdom.  But for the fan, the clause enhanced the game because it kept stars on the same teams for much if not all all of their careers. The 70’s and early 80’s was the era of great dynasties. [My own baseball card collection comprises all the playoff teams from 1969 – 1983, including the ’84 Royals and ’85 Royals and Dodgers.  The Orioles made 7 postseason appearances; the Yankees 5; the Royals 7; the A’s 6; the Phillies 6; the Pirates 6; the Reds 6; the Dodgers 6]

In 2010, Sky Andrecheck made a spirited defense of the Reserve Clause.  Andrecheck argues we could have all the virtue the reserve and still pay players what they are worth.


Skimming through the 1972 S & S, I did not find a single reference to the designated hitter. The DH would be introduced to the American League in 1973.  In Royals 4 – Mets 3. An opening day World Series rematch with Eugene Kramer , I make a qualified argument that having the DH in just one league might be acceptable. But if the DH ever becomes universal, 1972 will be the last year of the golden age.

SEE ALSO 48 years ago when Rochester saw its first “Designated Pinch Hitter”


In 1972, offenses were not as turbo charged as today. Hence, in S & S you could find articles about the art of bunting and getting hit by the pitch.


1972 S & S


In 1972, the splitting of the Leagues into divisions with playoffs was only three years old. The staid S & S objected, preferring the unfettered drama of the stand alone World Series.

I am not such a purist that I object to divisions which became necessary with expansion (itself a necessary sin against absolute purity).   That said, the postseason should be strictly limited. The four teams in 1972 was ideal as opposed the abomination of today’s three tiered playoffs.


1973 Topps Playoffs and World Series [from David Kramer’s collection]

Furthermore, baseball was superior from 1969 – 1984 when the League Championship Series were a best of five.  Perhaps the most exciting baseball of all time took place during those taut, short series that hinged on a handful of mistakes.  1972 produced the two of the greatest series in history when the A’s beat the Tigers in five and the Red beat the Pirates in five with both game fives decided by a run.


Middling. They predicted correctly on two of the four division winners.


S & S correctly predicted that the Pirates would win the NL East for the third straight year. With the loss of Clemente, the Pirates slipped in ’73 but won titles in ’74 and ’75 and then the Series in ’79


S & S was wrong on the AL East, thinking the Orioles would win their fourth straight crown. But the Tigers, led by aging stars Lolich, Kaline, Freehan and Cash, proved they had one more run in them after winning the ’68 series. In an oddity, the Tigers won the Division with the smallest margin possible. One half game. In April the players had gone on strike resulting in teams playing between 6 and 9 less games than scheduled, allowing the Tigers to win by that one half game over the Red Sox.


Even though the Reds had made it to the 1970 Series, S & S placed them third in the NL West, But the Reds won as they were beginning to accumulate the Big Red Machine that won the division in ’73 and two straight World Series in ’75 and ’76.


S & S correctly predicted the A’s would win the AL West, the second of five consecutive titles with three World Series Championships (’72-’74)


Make Predictions. Win cash.

30 years ago when George Brett won the World Series (and Morganna the Kissing Bandit)

30 years ago when Billy Buck broke Rhode Island’s heart

48 years ago when Rochester saw its first “Designated Pinch Hitter”

About The Author

Welcome to Talker of the Town! My name is David Kramer. I have a Ph.D in English and teach at Keuka College. I am a former and still active Fellow at the Nazareth College Center for Public History and a Storyteller in Residence at the SmallMatters Institute. Over the years, I have taught at Monroe Community College, the Rochester Institute of Technology and St. John Fisher College. I have published numerous Guest Essays, Letters, Book Reviews and Opinion pieces in The New York Times, Rochester Democrat and Chronicle, the Buffalo News, the Rochester Patriot, the Providence Journal, the Providence Business News, the Brown Alumni Magazine, the New London Day, the Boston Herald, the Messenger Post Newspapers, the Wedge, the Empty Closet, the CITY, Lake Affect Magazine and Brighton Connections. My poetry appears in The Criterion: An International Journal in English and Rundenalia and my academic writing in War, Literature and the Arts and Twentieth Century Literary Criticism. Starting in February 2013, I wrote for three Democratic and Chronicle  blogs, "Make City Schools Better," "Unite Rochester," and the "Editorial Board." When my tenure at the D & C  ended, I wanted to continue conversations first begun there. And start new ones.  So we created this new space, Talker of the Town, where all are invited to join. I don’t like to say these posts are “mine.” Very few of them are the sole product of my sometimes overheated imagination. Instead, I call them partnerships and collaborations. Or as they say in education, “peer group work.” Talker of the Town might better be Talkers of the Town. The blog won’t thrive without your leads, text, pictures, ideas, facebook shares, tweets, comments and criticisms.


Like what you see on our site? We’d appreciate your support. Please donate today.

Featured Posts