Herman Melville in Rochester, 1840, 1846 and 1858

Herman Melville in Rochester, 1840, 1846 and 1858

Richard Tobias Greene, who jumped ship with Melville in the Marquesas Islands and is Toby in Typee, pictured in 1846 (Project Gutenberg)

In the summer of 1840, a twenty one year old Herman Melville quit his teaching post in Greenbush, New York after one term because he had not been paid. Idle, Melville and his friend James Murdock Frey left their upstate homes near Troy to journey to Galena, Illinois, seeking adventure and the help of Melville’s uncle to find them work.

Taking packet boats and trudging by foot along the Erie Canal, the two passed through Rochester. If the boom town left any impressions on Melville, he did not record them. Melville was more taken with Buffalo, strolling Canal Street with its bustling Lake Erie and Erie Canal traffic. Its smaller eastward cousin on Lake Ontario overlooked, Buffalo even appears in Moby-Dick as the “land-locked heart of our America.”

Wilson Helin's Herman Melville's Whaling Days (2005) contains the fullest account available on the life of Richard Tobias Greene

Wilson Helin’s Herman Melville’s Whaling Days (2005) contains the fullest account available on the life of Richard Tobias Greene. [Held at an scanned courtesy of the Rush Rhees library, University of Rochester]

Not finding suitable employment in Illinois, upon his return to New York, Melville signed aboard the whaler Acushnet as a “Boy” for 1/175th of the voyage’s profit: thus beginning his oceanic voyages that became the scenes for most of his fictions.

Six years later in July 1846 — this time travelling by train — Melville returned to Rochester for a more memorable occasion: reuniting with Richard Tobias “Toby” Greene who had come forth to authenticate Melville’s recently published first novel, Typee: A Peep at Polynesian Life.

In July 1842, while whaling on the Acushnet, Melville and Toby — from Rochester — deserted or “jumped ship” in the South Pacific Marquesas Islands, spending a month on the island of Nuku Hiva where Melville closely observed Polynesian customs, including cannibalism. (Although the Typee natives who captured Melville did eat inhabitants of a neighboring valley, Melville and Toby were reassured that they would not be eaten.)

Based on Melville and Toby’s actual experiences — with imaginative reconstruction and adaptation of material from other books — Typee was widely popular, drawing critical acclaim in England and the United States, eliciting comparisons with Daniel Defoe’s classic travel and adventure narrative Robinson Crusoe.

At the same time, as explained by Wilson Hefflin in Melville’s Whaling Years (2004), despite its praiseworthiness, many contemporary critics raised the issue of Typee‘s authenticity.  Hefflin writes, “Had Melville’s first book been published as a novel, a tale of romance, rather than as a factual travel book, contemporary readers would have had no reason to be incredulous.”

Melville was indignant by charges against his veracity. But, as Hefflin says, it was Melville’s word against the critics.  Suddenly, Richard Tobias Greene — Melville’s fellow deserter and lone eyewitness — dramatically appeared — or reappeared.

Details on Toby’s date place of birth are sketchy; he was probably born in Dublin, Ireland but may have been born in Rochester or immigrated to the city as a young child. According to Toby’s obituary, in Rochester he took public school and academic courses.  Later, Toby studied law in Canandaigua, NY with the well known attorney John Canfield Spencer, also a former Congressman and Secretary of War. Toby was admitted to the bar, but before practicing law, went to sea on the Acushnet.

Rochester Daily Democrat (Rochester, New York) - May 12, 1847 (melvilliana.blogspot.com).

By the time of this favorable of Omoo, the sequel to Typee, Typee‘s authenticity was accepted. Rochester Daily Democrat – May 12, 1847

As described by the Democrat and Chronicle‘s Jim Memmott, “A high seas mutiny with a Canandaigua connection,” Spencer’s son, Philip, was executed in 1842 for plotting a mutiny while a sailor on the USS Somers. In a literary/historical coincidence, Philip became the model for Billy Budd in Melville’s posthumously published novel. Both to be immortalized by Melville, quite possibly Toby and Philip knew each other in Rochester or Canandaigua as student and son respectively of the elder Spencer. We don’t know if Toby returned to Rochester or Canandaigua after his South Sea voyage, but by 1845 had established himself as a house and sign painter in Buffalo.

According to Hefflin, on April 9th, 1846 Toby read a review of Typee in the New York Evangelist, prompting a remarkable July 1 letter sent to The Buffalo Commercial Advertiser claiming he was the Toby of Typee and defending its accuracy.  Apparently, not knowing how to find Melville, Toby wrote the letter as a means of contact. The tactic worked; Melville saw the letter the next day and soon arranged a rendezvous. On July 11th, Toby sent a second longer letter to the Commercial Advertiser entitled “Toby’s Own Story” and sometime between July 15th and July 22nd the two meet.

Though some speculate the meeting was in Buffalo where Toby lived, according to Melville’s biographer Herschel Parker, it was in Rochester, possibly at Toby’s Rochester family home. In an August 4th notice in the Albany Evening Journal editor Thurlow Weed —  initially skeptical of the existence of Toby — locates the reunion in Rochester, saying the visit lasted two or three days.

Albany Evening Journal - August 4, 1846 (meliv

Albany Evening Journal – August 4, 1846 (via GenealogyBank )

A year or so later, Parker cites Weed review of Melville’s next book Omoo. Weed says:

These Marqesans adventurers [Melville and Toby] met subsequently in Rochester to assure themselves, as well a doubting public, of their respective identity and existence.”

According to Hefflin, no records have been found of what was discussed in Rochester, but apparently out of the conversation came a sixteen page sequel to Typee, “The Story of Toby,” later included in revised editions of the book. Exhilarated by seeing Toby again, Parker speculates Melville began composing “The Story” immediately on the train ride home.

We do know that Toby gave Melville a daguerreotype (or perhaps the image was made during the visit) and a lock of Toby’s hair that Melville called “those ebon curls.” Although not seeing each other again, Melville and Toby maintained a warm correspondence for many years.

11 years later in May 1857, Melville returned to America from a seven-month trip to Europe and the Levant including a stop in Italy.  Under financial strain, Melville took advantage of the 19th century vogue for visiting lecturers and joined the lyceum circuit. In 28 cities, mostly across the northeast and Canada, from May 1857 – February 1858, Melville delivered “Statues in Rome” [from Melville as Lecturer (1957) by Merton M. Sealts, Jr. Scanned courtesy of the Robbins Library, University of Rochester].

Based on Melville’s observations of ancient Roman statuary, the lecture asked: “Can art, not life, make the ideal?” — in which Melville answered in the affirmative. The lectures proved less popular and remunerative than Melville hoped. According to Parker, income amounted to $645.00, which after subtracting $221.30 in travelling expenses, left a profit of  $423.70, enough only to pay taxes and some debt.

Advertisements and advance notices for Melville's lecture from Rochester Daily Democrat and Rochester Union and Advertiser

Advertisements and advance notices for Melville’s lecture from Rochester Democrat and American and the Rochester Union and Advertiser. [Courtesy of Local History & Genealogy Division Rochester Public Library]

At Rochester’s Corinthian Hall, on February 18th, 1858, sponsored by the Atheneum and Mechanics’ Association,  Melville presented “Statues in Rome”.

One of the pleasures of scholarship — amateur or professional — is following in the steps of previous researchers. Merton M. Sealt Jr.’s 1957 Melville as Lecturer is the most comprehensive account of Melville’s speaking career including the talk at Corinthian Hall.


Melville as Lecturer (1957) by Merton M. Sealts, Jr. [Held at and scanned courtesy of the Rossell Hope Robbins Library and Koller-Collins Center for English Studies River Campus Libraries]

When searching for what little we know of Melville’s 1858 lecture, I trod along the same paths as did Sealts. As seen in the footnotes below, Sealts asked Rochester Public Librarians Miss Gladys E. Love and Miss Emma Swift to search the files of the Rochester Democrat and American and Union and Advertiser for advance notices and reviews. Today, our thanks go to Master Michael J. Nighan who dutifully scoured the microfilms, finding the same pieces.  I also contacted Jody Sidlauskas, Associate Archivist at the Rochester Institute of Technology, holder of the Rochester Athenaeum and Mechanics’ Association collection.  As Miss Love and Miss Swift also discovered, the 1858 RAMA Annual Report makes no mention of Melville.

Melville Rochester

Melville as Lecturer (1957) by Merton M. Sealts, Jr [Held at and scanned courtesy of the Rossell Hope Robbins Library and Koller-Collins Center for English Studies River Campus Libraries]

While the Democrat and American review praised Melville’s “mystic philosophy” and considered “Statues of Rome” proof of Melville’s aesthetic acumen, the overall tenor was negative.  The lecture was boring.  From the reviewers’ perspective, the mass of Rochester lecture goers knew little about ancient history and cared less for Melville’s musing on old monuments, dismissed much like Melville as “sermons in stones.”  Mistaking his role as a “popular lecturer,” Melville “erred in his choice of a theme.” Finally, Melville was capable of “doing better.”

Daily Democrat

Rochester Daily Democrat, February 20th, 1858. [Courtesy of Local History & Genealogy Division Rochester Public Library]

As catalogued by Sealts, while quite a few adulatory reviews appeared in other venues, similar critiques were made.  In some cities, Melville’s dramatic performance was panned; he spoke either too slowly, softly or in a monotone with too few theatrical flourishes.  Similarly, other reviewers felt the lecture was highly commendable, but better suited as an essay.  As in Rochester, a common refrain was the lecture was too remote, bookish or unattractive to the masses.  The Boston Journal wanted something “more modern and personal.”  Along those lines, the more caustic “Reporter” of the Bunker-Hill Aurora complained that except for a single bit of conversation which Melville had quoted, the “Reporter” would “hardly have guessed he [Melville] had ever been to Italy at all.” At the same time, a critic in Clarksville blamed not Melville but a provincial, popular taste incapable of responding on as a high level of culture as Melville’s subject and treatment demanded.

The next lyceum season — perhaps expediently yielding to the observation of the Rochester reviewer that Melville had erred in his choice of subject — Melville instead wrote and delivered, “The South Seas.” Melville realized his sea voyages and sea narratives — replete with sensational topics like tattooing, taboos and cannibalism — were more amenable to popular taste.  Although he delivered “The South Seas” fewer times than “Statues of Rome” — and not in Rochester — Melville exceeded his previous take, clearing $518.50.


As far as determined, until now, Melville’s lecture at Corinthian Hall escaped the notice of local historians. In a piece on Corinthian Hall, rocwiki.org lists many luminaries who spoke at the hall: Frederick Douglass, Susan B Anthony, Ralph Waldo Emerson, Charles Dickens, William H Seward, and William Lloyd Garrison.  Today, we can add perhaps America’s greatest author.

On February 18th, 1858, sponsored by the Atheneum and Mechanics' Association, to a full house at Rochester's Corinthian Hall, Melville presented "Statues in Rome".

On February 18th, 1858, sponsored by the Atheneum and Mechanics’ Association, to a full house at Rochester’s Corinthian Hall, Melville presented “Statues in Rome”.

cropped 2 brightene new

Rochester in 1853 between Melville’s 1846 and 1858 visits. Reproduced in 1973 by HISTORICAL URBAN PLANS, Ithaca, New York from a lithograph in the Cornell University Library. This is number 208 of an edition limited to 500 copies. [Owned by David Kramer]

SEE ALSO Melville’s Mighty Theme: A Visit to Herman Melville’s Home in Lansingburg, NY.

About The Author


Welcome to Talker of the Town! My name is David Kramer. I have a Ph.D in English and teach at Keuka College. I am a former and still active Fellow at the Nazareth College Center for Public History and a Storyteller in Residence at the SmallMatters Institute. Over the years, I have taught at Monroe Community College, the Rochester Institute of Technology and St. John Fisher College. I have published numerous Guest Essays, Letters, Book Reviews and Opinion pieces in The New York Times, Rochester Democrat and Chronicle, the Buffalo News, the Rochester Patriot, the Providence Journal, the Providence Business News, the Brown Alumni Magazine, the New London Day, the Boston Herald, the Messenger Post Newspapers, the Wedge, the Empty Closet, the CITY, Lake Affect Magazine and Brighton Connections. My poetry appears in The Criterion: An International Journal in English and Rundenalia and my academic writing in War, Literature and the Arts and Twentieth Century Literary Criticism. Starting in February 2013, I wrote for three Democratic and Chronicle  blogs, "Make City Schools Better," "Unite Rochester," and the "Editorial Board." When my tenure at the D & C  ended, I wanted to continue conversations first begun there. And start new ones.  So we created this new space, Talker of the Town, where all are invited to join. I don’t like to say these posts are “mine.” Very few of them are the sole product of my sometimes overheated imagination. Instead, I call them partnerships and collaborations. Or as they say in education, “peer group work.” Talker of the Town might better be Talkers of the Town. The blog won’t thrive without your leads, text, pictures, ideas, facebook shares, tweets, comments and criticisms.


Like what you see on our site? We’d appreciate your support. Please donate today.

Featured Posts